Connect with:
Thursday / November 19.
HomeCompaniesWhy tax break on tiles should be dropped if Marcopolo & Twyford tiles refuse to list on LUSE

Why tax break on tiles should be dropped if Marcopolo & Twyford tiles refuse to list on LUSE

Undoubtedly, investments by Marcopolo Tiles – which is part of the Wonderful Group companies in Zambia has resulted in visible and tangible benefits, one of the first being the cut in retail and wholesale prices of tiles which had earlier been an imported product. Floor and wall tiles were unaffordable for most local households and even business, a situation which is not the same today. Zambia was also a net importer as there was really no major industrial scale tile manufacturing in Zambia.

This was despite the fact that Zambia had always been rich in natural resources like limestone, one of the main ingredient in tile manufacturing process. In fact, Marcopolo tiles itself in April 2022 revealed that it sources 98% of its raw materials used to make its products from within Zambia.

The Zambian Business Times – ZBT was one if not the first media to have showcased the tangible benefits that this Wonderful group of companies pledged to deliver for Zambia. In September 2021, UCF had told the Zambian Business Times that “the Wonderful group would build a large fertiliser plant that will cut the importation of fertiliser for Zambia by about 60% and reduce the cost of fertiliser by about 40% due to use of local raw materials and economies of scale”. See link… https://zambianbusinesstimes.com/new-300m-fertilizer-plant-to-cut-prices-by-40

One of the weakest areas for the Zambia government system has been its fronting of officials who lack the necessary negotiating skills and experience and at most times, fronting officials to negotiate who are either corrupt and only secures their personal or private interest, leaving the country to hang high and dry. Today, the wonderful group has expanded aggressively but limited efforts are being made to have this group list on LuSE so that citizens and Zambians can own a share.

Some will be quick to argue that IDC already has a share in Wonderful group, but its common knowledge that most of these shares owned at that level of have little to no tangible benefits that trickle down to the larger population compared to listing on LuSE. Zambia through its investment wings send representative directors on these boards, but the benefits to the country by these ownerships through ZCCM IH, IDC remain a mirage apart from the benefits drawn by the representative directors and some little trickle down to the investment company.

If you look at the 2027 budget, revenue resource envelop you will see that dividends or benefits from government earnings from its about $6 billions investments in various IDC companies and through ZCCM IH account for next to nothing as far as financing annual national expenditure is concerned. In fact, there is no single line item in the summarised revenue resource envelop that dividends from IDC/ZCCM-IH make.

With the above in mind, it then makes better sense for LuSE, a government agency to partner with the Ministry of Finance and add on the table the need to initiate listing on LuSE as part of the negotiating chip for the value that these companies would get from getting the sweet deals of tax incentives. That way, the country will take away the incentive for corrupt officials to hand these BIG incentives at no wider society benefit, other than themselves or their political benefactors taking all the benefits.

Assuming our parliament miraculously ends its political debates and decides to concentrate on real economic and social issues that face the majority Zambians, they could demand that listing of shares by the key players in the tile making industry list on LuSE and shared offered to local Zambian citizens as a condition for voting for the budget to pass. But hey, with the level and caliber of debate coming from especially some nominated members, this may be too much to ask.

The top two locally based but Chinese owned tile making companies – Marcopolo of Wonderful group and Keda Investments should be asked to list on LuSE and offer Zambians a share of the company. This will not only lead to improved transparency in their operations, but also ensure that tax incentives handed to companies benefit the wider Zambian citizenry.

The proposal above is not just about Marcopolo or Keda giving up a part of their stake to local citizens, it is also about negotiating how the benefits that will accrue from the incentives will be distributed equitably.

Other wise, the Finance Ministers speech stating that “industrialisation and value addition are central to the Grow Zambia Agenda. To this end, Government will continue to promote an environment in which local industries can expand production, compete effectively, create employment and contribute to economic diversification. I therefore propose [to] increase customs duty on ceramic tiles to 40 percent from 25 percent to promote the local ceramic industry” will only result in a few mostly low paying jobs accruing as benefits to Zambia in the medium to long term.
Article by Donald Mumba – Managing Editor of ZBT